Homemade Cheese

We’re getting cheesy this month for First on the First! With homemade cheese, that is. Taking something into our own kitchens that we’ve only trusted professionals with before.

Homemade Ricotta(eque) Cheese

After reading The Whole Fromage for my virtual book club, From Left to Write, I became quite enamored with the idea of cheesemaking. France has this wonderful history of regional cheeses–hundreds, in fact–varying from village to village. I wish I could say I have intimate knowledge of a rich tradition like this, but alas, I do not. The oldest recipe in my arsenal comes from my mom–a method for making mac and cheese that we both learned from the high school Foods department. We just don’t have recipes passed down from generation to generation like that, and certainly nothing having to do with manipulating milk.

Homemade Ricotta(eque) Cheese

There was a short period in my life when I entertained the thought of raising goats. (And llamas. And chickens. For some reason, I seem to think I’m a farmer.) I went on a bender viewing The Fabulous Beekman Boys last year, fueling the fire. Reading The Lost Husband contributed further to my fantasy life. Romanticized ideas about goat farming danced in my head, squashed immediately by a husband dead set against any agricultural lifestyle I could imagine. It’s not meant to be.

Homemade Ricotta(eque) Cheese

What I didn’t realize is that I didn’t need the farm to make the cheese. Or massive caves in special terroir, either. Simple tastes could be satisfied with simple cheeses, right from my own kitchen.

Cheese is much more of a scientific journey than an interpretive dance. Exactness is key, often right down to the temperature reached and for how long sustained. This can pose some bigger challenges for neophytes. Kate‘s cheese, sadly, did not survive the process. She’ll share her experience with us in her Weekend Whisk wrap-up on Saturday. Anna expressed some concerns about hers, as well. More forays into the First on the First-ers’ cheesemaking can be found here:

Next month we’ll be twisting and turning away… making candy canes! Just in time for the holiday season! If you’d like to join us, click on the #FirstOnTheFirst tab above for more information. The more, the merrier!

Homemade Ricotta(eque) Cheese

And now, my homemade cheese. I discovered the method on The Italian Dish. While this isn’t a “true” ricotta in that it wasn’t started with whey from already-made cheese (ricotta meaning, literally, recooked), the end result is a close-enough substitute for the real deal, and certainly superior to supermarket alternatives. The procedure is quite easy and other than some babysitting of the pot to ensure you don’t scorch the milk, there isn’t a whole lot to it–including no need for thermometers and precise timing of a multitude of steps. This is the perfect cheese for the first-timer. Bolstered by this success, I’m looking forward to delving deeper in the future.

5.0 from 2 reviews
Homemade Ricotta(esque) Cheese
Prep time
Cook time
Total time
Recipe type: Cheese
Serves: 2+ cups
  • 2 quarts (1/2 gallon) organic whole milk
  • 1 cup organic heavy cream
  • ¾ teaspoon Maldon salt
  • 2 Tablespoons freshly squeezed lemon juice (1 lemon should be sufficient)
  1. Place a wire mesh strainer over a 2-quart bowl and line with 2 layers of cheesecloth. Set aside.
  2. In a large, heavy-bottomed sauce pan (I used my 6-quart enameled cast iron pot), whisk together the milk, cream, and salt.
  3. Cook over medium to medium high heat, stirring often, until it comes to a rolling boil. This will take a while. Be patient and don't rush it, or you will ruin the milk.
  4. Once the milk has achieved a rolling boil, reduce the heat to medium-low and stir in the lemon juice.
  5. Stir constantly, continuing to cook for 2 more minutes.
  6. Ladle the curds into the cheesecloth-lined strainer, allowing the whey to drain through into the bowl.
  7. Let sit for about 20 minutes before transferring to a covered container and refrigerating. (You can let it drain longer, but it will be dryer; conversely, less time draining will make a moister cheese.)
  8. Use within 48 hours.
*I highly recommend going with the highest quality ingredients possible here. If you're going to go through the effort to make your own cheese, you may as well make the best cheese possible. Organic milk, therefore, is a must here. Next time, I will be trying to make this with raw milk.
*The whey that remains can be used in breadmaking as a liquid replacement. Since there is no rennent in this cheese, however, it cannot be used to make other cheese.

Do you dream of cheese? Which would you like to try making?

Homemade Ricotta(eque) Cheese

Print Friendly, PDF & Email


Skip to comment form

    • Alyssa D. {Suitcases & Sweets} on 1 November, 2013 at 12:12 pm
    • Reply

    Didn’t this challenge make you wonder why we by ricotta from the grocery store? It’s SO easy to make. (And I can’t imagine they use whey from already-made cheese either!) Great challenge and post this month, Carrie!

  1. Well this looks doable! Beautiful job, Carrie!

    • Ruthy @ Omeletta on 1 November, 2013 at 6:15 pm
    • Reply

    This was such a great challenge for First on the First, Carrie! I’m sorry I didn’t get to participate- I tried making goat cheese THREE TIMES this month, and every batch failed to make anything even sort of resembling a curd, so I was forced to throw in the towel (and looking forward to reading what Kate has to say about her cheese!). So I’m way impressed that you carried through. Ricotta is one of my great loves, it’s so simple to make and it tastes a million times better than anything you can buy in the store. Very much looking forward to Candy Canes next month!

    1. Goat cheese!!! I know you’re a goat cheese addict like me 😉 I would love to try making homemade goat cheese. Sorry yours ran into issues Ruthy but thanks for your valiant efforts!

  2. Your ricotta is beautiful! I’ve made ricotta before and love the flavor and freshness so much more than store-bought. I’m so happy you found success with your first homemade cheese!

  3. I love to make ricotta and it does taste so much better than store bought and it’s so easy!

  4. Hi Carrie,

    I was thrilled to read this article and the joy you got from making ricotta.

    Making cheese at home is a passion of mine and people don’t realise just how easy it can be (and a very rewarding way to spend half a day in the kitchen!).

    If any of your readers would like to take their cheese making adventure further, I have created a free eBook which is a beginner’s guide to making cheese at home. It can be downloaded on my website: http://www.homemadecheese.org where there is a ton of other information on cheese making too.

    Thanks for making my day with your writing!


    • Jenny on 6 November, 2013 at 5:05 pm
    • Reply

    OOOooo yours looks soooo gooood! I wish I drained mine a little more! I want to eat that flatbread right off of my screen! 😀 YUM!

    1. Funny because I used the rest in a pasta bake and it probably shouldn’t have been drained quite so much… but it was still very tasty!

    • AprilRain78 on 22 February, 2014 at 9:43 am
    • Reply

    That looks amazing!! Ive always wanted to learn the “basic” foods! Like cheese (also bread)…… but I would love to learn how to make cream cheese! April

    1. Cream cheese isn’t much of a stretch from here. I haven’t made it myself, but when I’ve read about it, it’s always listed as one of the easier cheeses to make. Don’t be intimidated–go for it!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Rate this recipe:  

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.