Cheesecake Cookie Sandwiches

This is the kind of recipe dreams are made of. For this adaptation so occupied my thoughts and haunted my dreams that I lost almost an entire night of sleep over it, once I saw the original photo on Food Porn Daily. Yes, I’m talking about this photo of Cheesecake with a Chocolate Chip Cookie Crust from In Katrina’s Kitchen. Those billowy puffs of cheesecake clouds softly floating upon a crispy, cookie shell… how could that not excite ones inner most fantasies? It truly became a cheesecake obsession!

From the start, however, I envisioned the assembly slightly altered. It’s not that I think Katrina’s concoction needed work, because it surely does not. She struck gold with this idea! But I felt this strong pull to re-envision her work and look at it in a different light. I had to make it!

“Making” is a whole other story these days. With my recent discectomy and activity restrictions, I’m not really capable of cooking or baking right now. Rather than cooling the flames, though, this limitation fueled the fires already burning bright, desire winning out over rest. There had to be a way to make this work! Could someone lay out all the equipment and ingredients in advance, so that I may carry out the task without risk of re-injury? Or better yet, could I convince my mostly non-baking, non-cooking husband to work as my hands, following the blueprints in my mind to create this confection of perfection? He was not so sure. Luckily for you, I was able to convince him otherwise.

cheesecake cookie sandwich

My first attempt at the no-bake cheesecake portion was a flop. Katrina’s version of it is largely what influenced me to try this alteration but when I blended together the ingredients for it, my cheesecake was quite loose. Too loose. I figured maybe it was supposed to set up as it cooled, so I had The Big Guy package it up and we put it in the refrigerator, dutifully waiting out five hours. Unfortunately, it never magically transformed into that fluffy consistency captured in Katrina’s picture–mine refused to cooperate, remaining a syrupy mess instead. There weren’t many steps to follow, so I’m not sure where I went wrong. Given the fact that I was planning on making Cheesecake Cookie Sandwiches anyway, however, I decided to throw the un-set cheesecake into my ice cream maker with 1 cup of heavy whipping cream and turn it into cheesecake ice cream instead. That worked–sort of.

The Big Guy then took on the role of cookie maker, under my tutelage. Even though I should have kept to the sidelines, I mixed the batter myself (shame on me, I know!) and had him put it in the fridge for an hour, due to the high humidity and temps in our apartment. Then he scooped out huge dough balls (6 per cookie sheet!) so we’d get beefy cheesecake cookie sandwiches. It took a couple batches, but he caught on quickly and soon, he reached perfection on his own. Big, chewy cookies that were begging to be paired up.

cheesecake cookie sandwich

Our first attempt at assembly was less-than-satisfactory. They tasted just fine, the cheesecake ice cream being an especially tasty treat, but despite waiting several hours for the ice cream to solidify, it would not hold its shape once added to the cookies. It was adequate for immediate gratification, so I knew it was a winning combination. But the wrapped sandwiches didn’t freeze fast enough, resulting in a puddle of ice cream that seeped under the cookies–delicious, but disgusting looking. A second attempt was required.

For my next try, I went back to the no-bake cheesecake and decided to re-work that. I used mascarpone cheese this time, doubling the amount to ensure a thicker end product. This worked! I decided to forgo making it into ice cream and go with my original plan of cheesecake cookie sandwiches. After letting the cheesecake mix sit in the fridge for a couple hours, I piped it onto the cooled cookies. I highly recommend wrapping the assembled sandwiches up at this point and letting them sit in the fridge for a few hours before eating–the cookies soften and the flavors all meld together. YUM. Success!

Cheesecake Cookie Sandwiches–portion control of two of my favorite desserts so you can feel indulgent without indulging too much.

cheesecake cookie sandwich

Cheesecake Cookie Sandwiches

No Bake Cheesecake
adapted from In Katrina’s Kitchen

  • 1 16-ounce tub mascarpone cheese
  • 1 14-ounce can sweetened condensed milk
  • 1 tsp vanilla extract

Blend the above in a large mixing bowl until creamy and well-incorporated. Cover and store in refrigerator for a couple hours until ready to assemble.

Chocolate Chip Cookies
adapted from Nestle Toll House Cookies recipe

  • 1 cup (16 Tbsp) butter, softened
  • 3/4 cup vanilla sugar
  • 3/4 cup brown sugar, lightly packed
  • 2 large eggs, room temperature
  • 1 tsp vanilla extract
  • 1 tsp fine sea salt
  • 1 tsp baking soda
  • 2 1/4 cups whole wheat pastry flour
  • 2 cups semi-sweet chocolate chips

Preheat oven to 375 degrees Fahrenheit. Pull out your cookie sheets and set aside.

In the bowl of a stand mixer, cream the butter and sugar until light and fluffy. Beat in the eggs, one at a time. Mix in the vanilla until well-incorporated. Sprinkle the sea salt and baking soda over the batter and gradually beat in the flour. Remove bowl from mixer and stir in the chocolate chips. At this point, you can refrigerate your dough for an hour or two (if it’s hot out, this will help prevent over-spreading) or proceed straight to baking.

Using a large cookie scoop, drop mounds of batter onto your cookie sheet, leaving plenty of room between the mounds for spreading (we did 6 per sheet). Flatten the mounds slightly. Bake for 8-10 minutes, then leave on cookie sheets for 2-3 minutes before transferring to a wire rack to cool completely.

To make the cheesecake cookie sandwiches:

Spoon or pipe cheesecake onto the flat side of a cookie. Apply the flat side of another cookie on top of it and gently press together. Wrap in saran wrap and place in refrigerator for another couple hours to meld flavors. Eat and enjoy!

Print Friendly, PDF & Email


1 ping

Skip to comment form

  1. It was fate that the first try didn’t set up because this my dear is SO ah-mazing! It is like something that you see in a magazine! Marscapone- brilliant!!

    1. It truly was serendipitous! I’m so glad I had yours as an inspiration though!

  2. Those look so amazing! I love this idea, thanks for sharing with us!

  3. Oh, boy, I’d be all over those cookies if they were in my kitchen….great idea…and they look perfect as they are!

  4. OK, Im loving the idea of a cheesecake cookie sandwich right now! That seems like heaven.

    • Lauren at Keep It Sweet on 2 June, 2011 at 9:21 pm
    • Reply

    Your adaptation is genius! This is a dream dessert!

    1. Thank you! It is pretty tasty!

  1. […] Cheesecake Cookie Sandwiches by Poet in the Pantry […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.